Looking for feedback for my comic idea.

Topic Tags:

A place for original short stories, fanfiction, essays, and the like. Keep it PG-13.

Moderator: Designers

Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby CrashQueen on Wed Jan 25, 2012 9:36 pm

No clue where else to put it, really.

So I sat myself down and thought through my characters and general idea, and I wanted other writers/rpers to throw in their two cents!

Image

Title: VOODOO IN STEREO
[I’m a little married to this title, but I’m willing to change it if something better comes up]



Characters:
MAIN CHARACTERS

Kevin Lewis: Your hero, he is a hipster-ish sort who makes money by drawing gig posters for shitty bands, selling prints on Etsy, and freelance graphic design. He’s about 23 years old and lives in an apartment with his college roommate, Archie. His hobbies include smoking, loitering, and tinkering with old electronics. He comes into possession of the Boombox, all because he wants to impress Casey, who barely notices his advances. He and Boombox Jones have to work as a team in order to defeat the obstacles that are thrown at him.

BOOMBOX JONES: A displaced soul that inhabits a boombox that Kevin comes across. He’s not the nicest person, and he won’t hesitate to show it, so it’s really no surprise that he would end up in a piece of obsolete tech. Placed there by a jilted ex who just so happened to be a Witch, he uses Kevin as his body by-proxy to move himself around and get closer to getting his original body back. However, in order to break the spell, the Witch has to die.

SECONDARY CHARACTERS

Casey Allen: Cute but oblivious, Casey is a server at the Midnite Bite diner and one of Kevin’s friends from college. Casey made the fatal error of graduating with a BA in English, and the job market has not been kind. She aspires to be a best-selling YA author, and has submitted to several publishers, but so far, she’s come up empty. She’s bubbly and friendly and poor Kevin wants her BAD.

Archie [lastnamepending]: Kevin’s roommate and best friend. He works at a call center, even though he graduated with a film studies degree. While Boombox Jones appears to not like Kevin, he simply adores Archie and together they give the artist a hard fucking time. He inevitably gets swept up into this whole mess with Kevin and Boombox.

ANTAGONISTS

Phillip Tweedle: A smug-faced, ridiculously popular YA fiction writer who’s made bank with his vampire romance novels. He is dating Casey, much to Kevin’s dismay, and is constantly promising her that he will get her an ‘in’ with his publisher. [There’s more to him, but I want to leave that as a surprise.]

THE WITCH (as of yet unnamed): Boombox Jones’ ex-girlfriend, who essentially went psychobitch after he tried to dump her. She’s fairly powerful, and becomes aware that Boombox is looking for some sort of revenge. She uses a series of pawns and schemes to keep this from happening, trying to take Kevin out so Boombox is left without any proxy body. She’s already done this once before several years ago.

GENERAL:

Kevin and Boombox fight increasingly more vicious cronies of The Witch in order to get Boombox’s body back. Boombox can draw spiritual energy from sound energy, so he is only so powerful based on what music is playing through his vessel. The mood and even lyrics of the song determine what kind of powers he can manifest. In order to have any successful battle, the music has to change pretty rapidly, and so most of the sound energy Boombox needs to fight comes from mixtapes that Kevin puts together. Mixtapes are cool, right?

Hipsters and boomboxes.
It has a bit of a Scott Pilgrim feel, but I don’t want it to be Scott Pilgrim. I’m afraid it’ll be too much like Scott Pilgrim with ghosts.
Drippin' a little noise in yo' ears. Best wear plugs.
User avatar
CrashQueen
Member for 2 years



Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby Gasmask on Thu Jan 26, 2012 12:47 pm

Needs more references to me. Gasmask Ghost.

He'd totally fit.

Just kidding. I like it, I'd buy the entire series, keep going, I want to see this become an awesome comic series. I really don't have anything bad to say about the characters, they seem pretty deep. Phillip needs to be more edgy though.
Image
Tiko says:
I still wanna punch him in the face
Mid says: Gas 1, Mid 0.
User avatar
Gasmask
Member for 2 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby DestroytheOrcs on Wed Feb 08, 2012 5:35 am

You're afraid it will be too much like Scott Pilgrim, huh? I don't blame you. If it were my idea I'd be worried about that too. However, this does not need to deter you. Just one warning; the more you TRY to make it NOT like Scott Pilgrim (and this really goes true for any piece of work), the more likely it is going to turn out just like that. What you need to do is focus solely on YOUR story and YOUR ideas and do not worry about little things such as it resembling something else. IF you continue to focus on your own ideas and let your imagination take over then that it the best way to make sure it turns out all-original.

If someone reads it and says that they notice a little bit of Scott Pilgrim in it then that is fine, too. It is only natural for people to compare a new work to something else. It helps them to better understand it. BTW, I have never seen the Scott Pilgrim movie (I actually had to Google it before I realized what it was) so I don't really know anything about it.

Your comic idea, though looks wonderful. A spirit trapped inside of a boombox? REALLY? Fantastic! I see that our friendly neighborhood Gasmask suggested making Phillip more edgy. I suppose but I would say he needs to be more arrogant and that Archie needs to be the edgy one. I always found that 'film folks' are like directors; dynamically edgy. lol

As for the title; I don't know. I definitely suggest changing it from Voodoo in Stereo to anything else but I easily understand being in love with a title (I am still in love with the title of a novel I have yet to even consider writing). Maybe something like The Sound of Voodoo?
I don't know. If I ever get published I'm likely to be one of those authors who hands a finished novel to the publisher that says, "Untitled" and tell them to figure it out. lol

Your idea is definitely fresh! Keep on keepin' on because I'd love to read this some day.
"Kill the orcs, slay the orcs, destroy the orcs!"

"If the winds of change don't smell of blood then they are not worth sniffing." -Orc Proverb Concerning Change and Chaos

"Surrender and die with shame! Resist and die with pain!" -Orc Negotiation Proverb
User avatar
DestroytheOrcs
Member for 1 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby ViceVersus on Wed Feb 08, 2012 10:24 am

I'm liking the descriptions of all the characters. It does sound like you have a fairly rounded out roster. Have you ever read Mac Hall? For some reason I'm imagining the characters to be presented kinda like their later style.

I'm a fan of the name Voodoo in Stereo, honestly. It has a sort of alliterative ring to it that sticks in peoples' heads, haha.

What are you looking for, in way of feedback from us? Have you sketched anything or written anything up for this? That'd be helpful to see more where you are.
GREEN: THE MOVIE

When 18-year-old Max Fenton's skin turns bright green,
he must balance sudden stardom with his destructively dysfunctional family.


Green is a 10-minute short film written by YOURS TRULY, being produced by Tribeca Flashpoint Studios, LLC.
"Like" us on Facebook, check out our website, or DONATE.
User avatar
ViceVersus
Scholar and Designer
Member for 5 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby Ginger666 on Wed Feb 22, 2012 4:01 pm

Just write what's in your head, and everything will be saved. I had the same with The Incredible hulk, someone told me my Hell Man story was to similar.
User avatar
Ginger666
Member for 0 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby CrashQueen on Sat Mar 03, 2012 10:15 pm

I've actually tweaked around the characters a bit and I'm working on an outline for the first volume in one of my classes. I'll be posting that once it's nice and cleaned up. I've actually changed up the story a little bit in order to get away from the 'scott pilgrimyness' of it.

Mostly I was just looking for what people thought about it and what they wanted to see. I keep picking at my character designs, but I think I'm settled on at least Kevin's design. Here's a mockup for a comic page. I'm not completely happy with it though.
Somewhere in the middle of the comic

Jones' design is going to be something like This.
Probably a little thinner/skullier, actually, but eh.

I'll get my outline up soon, I have to have it finalized by Wednesday anyhow!
User avatar
CrashQueen
Member for 2 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby CrashQueen on Wed Mar 07, 2012 8:39 pm

HERE IS THAT LONG OUTLINE I PROMISED. I got a 'it's good' from my narrative teacher but I want to see what other people think because 'different tastes' ya know?

- The story opens up with the protagonist, Kevin (early twenties- freelance graphic designer; generic hipster with glasses and an attempt at ironic facial hair) entering a diner where Casey (former classmate, more acquaintance than legitimate friend) works. Casey is an English BA with aspirations to become a young adult best-selling author. He and she make small talk while he orders coffee and attempts to work out some sketches for a client, but it's obvious that his flirting is not going to get to her.

- Casey, however, invites Kevin to her birthday party, stressing that the shindig is gift-optional. Kevin takes this as a way to impress Casey and resolves to get her the best gift that will get her to notice him as a potential boyfriend. He's far too unassertive to just ask her out, so he rather get her to come to him.

- After searching for a few days, including asking his film-school alum roommate what he should get her, Kevin comes to the terrible conclusion that he doesn't know Casey that well at all. This crisis leads him into the pawn shop, searching and hoping until something catches his eye

- And what catches his eye is the Boombox. All quirky-cool and definitely something that Casey would like (functioning on the assumption that Casey liked music and throwback tech; fortunately for Kevin, this was correct), Kevin buys it without hesitation, despite getting a talk down on how crappy it was. Kevin assures the cashier that he's good with electronics and can fix the boombox up no problem

- After taking the boombox home, Kevin notices that there's a tape left in the tape deck. Curiosity wins and Kevin simply has to push 'play' to have a listen. The tape appears to be a recording of nothing, though Kevin swears he can hear a faint voice underneath. His roommate, however, hears just the scratching of the old tape. He also makes it clear to Kevin that this was the worst gift ever.

Kevin blames his hearing of voices on his lack of sleep and crashes in his room, leaving the tape playing. As the tape plays, the soul (ie; Jones) is embedded into the boombox.

- Jones is PISSED and wakes Kevin up by electroshocking him and demands an explanation. Kevin is unable to give him one and is more than a little freaked out by the sudden manifestation of a BEING OF ELECTROMAGNETIC ENERGY (aka a GHOST) in his room. He promptly passes out again, leaving Jones free to rummage about his things and make a general mess while he tries to figure out what happened to him and where he's been and why he has no body now.

- Unfortunately, his impromptu fainting session means that Kevin misses Casey's party. Which is just as well, because what if he had given her an apparently possessed boombox. That's a dealbreaker right there.

- Kevin wakes up and finds to his dismay that this is not a dream and that he really does have this angry entity living in his room via the boombox. With the initial shock worn off, Jones introduces himself and tries to explain what he can about how he probably ended up in this stereo anyhow.

- As it turns out, Jones was a fairly average guy, if not a kind of horrible one. He cheated on his girlfriend at the time with another chick that he met at a bar, and then tried to break up with her. She didn't take it too kindly, obviously. She revealed herself to be a witch of sorts, and used a soul-displacement spell via a personal tape recorder, essentially recording and locking his essence into the tape that had been in the boombox.

- Playing the tape transferred Jones' essence from the tape and into the boombox, allowing him to manifest. Kevin coins the name Boombox Jones for the spirit. Jones kind of digs the name, but can tell Kevin is a weenie because of the fainting. But what choice does he have?

- Kevin is not going to have any of this, and he attempts to get rid of the boombox by chucking it. However, he starts to feel pain, sick, and weak when he gets too far from where he's left the piece of equipment. He storms back to Boombox Jones and demands what's going on.

- Jones explains that since Kevin 'released' him, they are more or less bound together. Kevin just can't 'ditch' Jones or he'll die. Kevin cannot handle all these feels right now and decides he needs coffee to calm his jangled nerves. Jones promises that for the time being, he'll stay unseen to avoid complicating thins further, He's a jerk, not irrational.

- Kevin comes across Casey at the coffee shop and tries to apologize for missing the party. Casey forgives and compliment's Kevin's rad new boombox. And for the briefest of moments, it looks like she and Kevin might get together after all.

- And then Casey's new boytoy shows up. His name is Ben and guess what? Ben's a new star in the YA fiction scene, and he's wanting to help Casey break into the business. He seems almost too good to be true for her. Kevin's a nothing in compare.

- Defeated, Kevin returns home. Jones sees his opportunity and offers a deal. Kevin can help him track down his ex and get his body back, and Jones will help Kevin out in hooking up with Casey. He also mentions that there's something off about Ben, but he can't figure out what. They shake on the deal, and Jones electroshocks Kevin again because, frankly, it's fun.

- Now, Kevin has to balance the delicate tasks of maintaining his job, relationships with friends and his roommate, and hiding Boombox Jones while simultaneously being unable to stray too far from the piece of equipment and not look insane.

- At the same time, at encouragement and jabs from Jones, Kevin continues to attempt to flirt and win Casey's affections despite Ben being pretty much perfect.

- One night, Kevin is assaulted by a goth-looking fangirl, who doesn't seem to be all in her mind, and only speaks in bad prose. It is by sheer fluke that Kevin discovers that Jones makes a good weapon, if only because he had the radio on when they were attacked. Boombox Jones draws spiritual energy from sound energy, which makes him powerful enough to interact with things on the physical realm aside from Kevin. The strange catch is that 'how' he does that is determined by the mood or even the lyrics of that sound, or song playing'.

- Jones is about to lay a finishing blow because he's worked up and has no qualms about killing before Kevin intervenes. He couldn't KILL anybody! How in the hell was he going to explain that away to the cops? He really can't. Fortunately, at this time, a commercial for a sleep aid comes on, and Jones simply sends their goth girl attacker to sleep and they make their getaway.

- Fascinated by this discovery, Kevin sets out to test the limits of Jones' capabilities and decides that he will arm himself with a mixtape that he can play should trouble rear its ugly head again. The random attack kind of unnerved him.

- And it should, because a few days later, he was attacked again by more prose-spouting people at a bus stop. Once again, Jones does his thing using the mixtape Kevin's provided, but pretty much destroys the tape in the process. Kevin is mildly distraught because that was such a BOSS mix too.

- At this point, Kevin's become a pro at making mixtapes and he decides he's going to give one to Casey as a gift to make up for the fact that he failed to get her one for her party. When the time comes, he has second thoughts and misses his chance, and after dropping Casey off at her apartment, he kicks himself on the way home.

- He doesn't make it very far, however, before he's yet again attacked by a prose-spouting weirdo. Although, the large, would-be pro-fighter seems to be all the wrong kinds of person to be spewing this stuff. Kevin- reluctantly- gives Jones the mixtape he'd made for Casey in order to fend this more formidable enemy off after fumbling with the radio failed to yield results (and he probably gets roughed up for it). Jones defeats their adversary, at the expense of wrecking the tape pretty violently.

- Casey hears the commotion and goes out to investigate to find the laid-out mugger, and a beaten Kevin. She coddles him and asks if he's okay before picking up the discarded fragment of the mixtape, reading her name on the label. She asks if this was for her and Kevin sheepishly says 'yes'. Casey finds this gesture cutely romantic and in the moment, kisses Kevin.

- Kevin is left pining and little does he know that Ben saw the whole thing.

- The following days are suspiciously quiet. Jones and Kevin both suspect that something strange is happening. And then, in a random internet search, they uncover the source of the bizarre prose their attackers have been spouting- excerpts from Ben's book.

- Ironically, Casey invites Kevin with her to one of Ben's book signings. Jones, who as a now 'occult' being, can determine that things are going really strange. Ben has the power to make people submit to his will by autographing their copies of his book. These must have been the people attacking them! Everything clicks into place.

- Before Kevin and Jones can sneak away, Ben calls them out as the store closes. A FIGHT is going to go down. Casey tries to defuse the oncoming fight between Kevin and Ben, but Ben pushes her to the side. Ben calls Jones out and laughs, but won't explain why. This whips Jones into a fury and he and Kevin fight with such vigor! Naturally, Ben summons a small horde of fangirls, crying 'kill KILL for your [insert teenage heartthrob romance novel character name here]' and man do they try! When they are dispatched, Kevin and Jones turn on Ben next. A proper song comes on and Ben is sapped of his mind-bending ability and is left what he really is- a talentless hack.

- Shamed and defeated, Ben runs off with his tail between his legs, saying something along the likes of 'she's not going to be happy about this!'

- She?

- Of course, this means Casey is aware of a) occult things are going down and b) Jones. To everybody's relief, Casey not only takes well, but is delighted by this turn of events, confessing herself to be a bit of a fan of such things. She wants in on their goings-on, provided she can use it to write about.

- They agree, and it's looking good for Kevin AND Jones on both fronts.


- With Casey in tow, Kevin and Jones steal into Ben's now-abandoned apartment to search for clues and discover a tape. They play it- it's a documentation of Ben and the Witch [Jones' ex] striking a deal. The Witch sounds doting, affectionate, and willing to turn her 'sweetheart' into a famous author through her occult means. This, and some other mementos that had a distinctly occult feel to them left in the flat, pinpoint to a terrible truth- Casey and the Witch were being so PLAYED by Ben.

- Casey is of course horrified that she was cheated on and has the typical post breakup meltdown, and Kevin of course offers his shoulder to cry on.

-Casey realizes that Kevin's been caring and awesome all this time, and they get together. Sure, it's a rebound, which Jones later points out, but he's got the girl. Achievement unlocked! Bonus for not having to keep Jones a secret from Casey any longer.

- Jones is paranoid that Kevin is just going to leave him hanging since he has Casey now. Kevin reassures him that Jones is his bro now and he's ready to see this through to the end because he's not a mean person. He also says that Jones could learn from that, Good Samaritan-like.

As expected, the Witch comes to town, looking for revenge, looking for Casey. She's very subversive, merely asking around because she doesn't want to start something in public. She actually comes to the diner Casey works at and pretends that she is an average diner, scoping out the area.

- She does this for several nights, asking the different servers their names until she gets Casey. Fortunately this is the night that Kevin's visiting her, and Jones warns Casey that her customer is the Witch, and that she should use a different name if she asks. It will buy them some time.

- Casey does this, the Witch continues to be a perfect patron. Jones and Kevin slip outside to cause a distraction involving setting off car alarms. Startled and shrieking about hoodlums and her car, the witch leaves the diner, leaving her bag in the seat.

Casey roots through her bag and produces a tape marked with her name. She shows Kevin and Jones who confirms its a hoodoo tape. Thinking quickly, Kevin scrawls Casey's name in the Witch's handwriting on one of his mixtapes and slips it into the bag as a decoy before the Witch returns.

- Their success is very short-lived however, as they leave the diner at the end of Casey's shift and clean-up, they are ambushed by the Witch. She talked to the manager and learned that her server's name WASN'T Allison like Casey claimed, but Casey. And man is she PIIIISSED.

- All three of them brace for a fight and the Witch is stunned by Jones' appearance, citing that she thought he was too cool to be stuck with people like Kevin and Casey. Jones demands his body back and she laughs and whistles.

- From the back of her car crawls out Jones' empty shell of a body, only it isn't empty, and its rather zombie-like. Naturally it attacks them and a fight ensues. Jones is holding back, obviously, because he doesn't want to damage his own body! But if he fails, Kevin and Casey will get destroyed. It's the moment of truth. One or the other.

- Jones chooses his friends, and with one last tape change, the hoodoo tape, he deals a devastating blow that wrecks not only the witch, but destroys the empty hull of his would-be body, and messes up quite a few cars in the parking lot in the process.

- Damaged, the Witch snarls at all of them, especially Jones. A battle-damaged Kevin crawls to the boombox and presses record on the hoodoo tape.

- The Witch is furious at how Jones could ever choose some hipster losers over HER- HER! And then she says her name. The name is recorded onto the hoodoo tape. The light in her eyes fades and arcs for the tape. She drops.

- Jones ejects the tape and goes quiet, staring at both the Witch's now empty body and the smudge that was his. He sighs before turning and grinning to the damaged couple. “So should we burn it?”

- Kevin takes the tape and stuffs it in his pocket and nods, fishing for another tape to pop into the boombox. It is a hilarious fire-themed song- I'm thinking Disco Inferno or We Didn't Start the Fire. A fire is burning, and Casey and Kevin share a post-battle snuggle to which Jones growls 'get a room'. Smoke rises.

THE END.
User avatar
CrashQueen
Member for 2 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby DestroytheOrcs on Wed Mar 07, 2012 8:40 pm

Voodoo! Voodoo! *is singing* I love you, Voodoo! Voodoo! Voodoo! I wanna' do ... Voodoo! Huzzah!

You have mentioned that you have finished your outline for this wonderful idea! I .... WANNA .... SEE!! xD

Voodoo! Voodoo! I love you, Voodoo! Voodoo! Voodoo! I wanna' do ... Voodoo! Huzzah!

-Mins
User avatar
DestroytheOrcs
Member for 1 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby DestroytheOrcs on Wed Mar 07, 2012 9:49 pm

Well, well, well. It is certainly...interesting. And funny. And, and, I love it! My only problem is that I am having a hard time imagining it all in comic-book form (I'm not really an avid comic reader) so I am going to offer my critique as if it is not a comic. It is the best I can do. :)

First of I noticed that there was no interaction between Archie and Jones despite you saying that Boombox Jones actually likes Archie. In fact, I noticed that you did not even mention Archie. Did you decide to leave him out? I hope not as any interactions between Boombox Jones, Archie, and Kevin have a lot of potential for some good laughs. Then again, Archie did sort of seem like a side character who would make little contribution to the actual story so it might be best if you did leave him out. Honestly, though I do not think you could go wrong either way. Some Archie interaction would be interesting especially if Archie ended up being one of those silly stoner-type roommates who only makes an appearance for convenient comedic purposes. lol

I do have to say that I noticed a couple of deus ex machina in the form of a sleep aid commercial just happening to play when Jones decides to kill the crazed goth girl despite Kevin not wanting him to. I think having Jones kill her would have been a wonderful plot element in that it could add a real conscious burden on to Kevin. Then again, if you are trying to aim this comic towards a younger demographic then it is wholly understandable that you do not want such a death to occur as that could very well earn it an M-type rating.
Another deus ex machina I noticed was Ben just happening to see the innocent kiss between Kevin and Casey (I say innocent because I imagined it was just a peck on the cheek for Kevin's thoughtful gift). Is it necessary to the story for Ben to see that kiss and if so then why was he there to begin with? I find it hard to believe that Ben (being an arrogant cheater) would stop by simply to see her. Another bit was the recording they found between Ben and the Witch. It just seems too convenient (unless of course there is motive for Ben to be recording his interactions with the Witch but it seemed to me that she is really the one in control in their 'relationship').

By the way, I love the pro-fighter type coming to attack as this indicates that he is a fan of Ben's YA vampire-romance series and received his own autographed copy. It seems unlikely but then again you might be surprised by the sort of people that read those sort of books and so suddenly it is not so unlikely. (I have a friend who loves Twilight and you would never know it by talking to him.)

The Witch's demise does strike me as sort of sudden and I was hoping that her character would be indulged on a bit more.

Having Casey draw inspiration from her adventures with Kevin and Jones was a wonderful idea as well. An obvious one but wonderful none-the-less. If this is meant to be a series and not a single-comic deal then I might suggest holding off on Kevin and Casey's romance and leaving her more oblivious to Kevin's feelings and Kevin still too awkward to come out and just admit it.

Anyways, everything I have said might not help you at all as it is difficult to offer a critique on a comic idea when I have no visual images (and since comics are most certainly not my forte). I am much more use to commenting on writing style and what-not but comics are more dialogue-driven with pictures standing it for most narration. I have a couple of concerns though such as is this a one comic deal or is it meant to be a continuing series? I could understand this as being written as a bit of a pilot for a comic idea and I think that, that would be wonderful.

Your ideas are very fresh and wholly exhilarating. The voodoo powers (or hoodoo as you also used and IMO you should stick with one or the other, preferably 'voodoo' IMO) that you have shown so far are very edgy and way out there. This is a good thing in my book. I mean, an author who is able to entrap fanboys and fangirls in a trance by autographing his book for them? Awesome! I am getting a lot of comedic potential from it all while at the same time you have managed to maintain a very serious story line. There is nothing like a serious story that can still manage to make you smile.
Another power I found most entertaining is Jones' powers according to what is playing on the boombox (and having each new mix tape being destroyed after it is used was a wonderful limit so as not to let the character become overpowered). Despite my disagreement on the timing of the sleep aid commercial it was still super creative. (I just thought of what might happen should a commercial for Viagra suddenly pop up!!!) ((No pun intended.))

Now, I am no artist in terms of drawing or anything like that but I'd like to comment on what I have seen so far. Your picture of Jones is a lot as I imagined (though skinnier as you had mentioned) but I might suggest making him look sort of 'staticy' in a White Noise sort of sense. If you have not seen that movie then I suggest checking it out if not just for the inspiration of Jones' look. As for giving him more of a 'skully' look I actually feel that his face looks fine the way it is. Maybe even make it look more zombie-ish or with the same kind of expression you see on shrunken heads. I think that would be rather appropriate.

Again, a lot of my suggestions may not work if this is a sort of single-comic idea and only you can truly know what will work in your story. If your narrative teacher only gave you an "it's good" then he/she may not be a fan of this sort idea and as a teacher can only really give you a "professional opinion". The opinion of readers and true fans is all that really matters (not to say that you should ignore the critique of your narrative teacher, of course).

One last suggestion; I think you should work on why exactly Kevin cannot simply abandon Boombox Jones and get on with his life. Kevin becoming sick and possibly dying when too far away from the boombox seems to me to be overly-convenient (and not to mention that Jones seemed oddly concerned that Kevin would abandon him in the end after he got with Casey). Personally, I don't think I'd want to abandon something so cool regardless but then again I am not being attacked by crazed, goth fangirls either. lol

You have a wonderful idea going on here and please, please do not let anything or anyone discourage you from continuing. Even if it doesn't become published and sell-out on the shelves does not matter. You are letting your imagination flow not just through words but pictures as well and that is the best thing of all. You should be very proud!

-Mins
User avatar
DestroytheOrcs
Member for 1 years


Re: Looking for feedback for my comic idea. ( )

Postby CrashQueen on Wed Mar 07, 2012 10:41 pm

Thanks for the feedback.
I can understand your difficulty in seeing this as a comic. Comic outlines and prose outlines are a lot different. I'm going to see if I can address all your concerns as you see them. This does need some revision as I kind of rushed through it and I feel like I didn't get near enough feedback. This is still pretty basic and I'm probably going to fill it in as I write.

- I had decided to leave Archie oblivious to Boombox Jones, but perhaps I will bring him in as a comedic relief sort of character, the stoner roommate sort of trope. I think that could be funny.

- I am avoiding having anybody actually die in the story because I feel like I don't really NEED it, I had originally had people being killed left and right, but I was told I could risk losing readers that way. I'm personally on the fence about it. It really just comes down to what I want to do in that moment. This wasn't intended to be a very 'dark' story to begin with. I kind of want to keep it that way- maybe I'll feel differently when I get to that scene.

-The scene in mind takes place just outside of Casey's apartment, and it's conceivable that Ben was already there and saw them out of her apartment window or something. He doesn't really HAVE to be there though. I think I'll edit him out- thanks!

- The tape between Ben and the Witch doesn't need to be in there, I suppose, if they find other evidence that he's been cheating. I like to thing this tapedeck Voodoo priestess likes to make copies of her contracts on tape. I don't know why. That's what I had intended. I like coming back to the tape thing. There's just something so charming and nostalgic about them.

- I do a lot of timeskipping in the outline, so I know the Witch's demise seems sudden. Like I said this was kind of a rush job. But note, she's not actually dead, just recorded into a tape, so there's always a possibility she could come back later~

- I plan on doing this as a webseries, and I want to add a whole bunch of filler in between the main events, which will solve a lot of the 'too soon' problems.

-Basically this is just a set-up for a bunch of characters I want to continue to fool around with. I never really want Jones to retrieve his body and just become content with being this dickhole that lives in a boombox.

-Ah, yeah, I'm still trying to figure out a reason as to why Kevin just can't avoid all these grief by leaving Jones at home or just burying the boombox somewhere. My best idea was to come up with a bond between the two of them that's detrimental to Kevin in some way. I like 'or you'll die' reason, obviously, but it's still open to change. As for when Kevin gets Casey he could always just ignore Jones or something. I guess there is no reason for it. Jones seems like a pretty annoyingly persistent fellow. He could easily ruin Kevin's day if Kevin decides to be a dick and not help once he's got the girl.

Artwork!
- I've been going back and forth on whether Jones should be glitchy/staticky or soundwavey. I think staticky will work best but man is it going to be hard to draw that one right. I like him having pieces of himself flicker in and out of existence. So glitchy zombie got it. He's staying blue though.



Thanks for taking the time to read and critique, and I hope I've cleared up some things for you! Please let me know if you have any more questions/suggestions. I'm really in love with this idea and I want to make it as good as it can be before moving forward! I want to make this as sort of an ongoing comic series, and this plot is supposed to be a 'pilot' of sorts.

My final intention is playing around with the occult and 'magic' in the Hipster realm, which is what I'm familiar with, what I know, and what I love.
User avatar
CrashQueen
Member for 2 years



Post a reply

RolePlayGateway is a site built by a couple roleplayers who wanted to give a little something back to the roleplay community. The site has no intention of earning any profit, and is paid for out of their own pockets.

If you appreciate what they do, feel free to donate your spare change to help feed them on the weekends. After selecting the amount you want to donate from the menu, you can continue by clicking on PayPal logo.

 

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests