Ben avoided meeting Marty's eyes as he shut the door after them and only glanced at Jo once, with a look that conveyed sudden weariness. He left them with a obviously distracted nod of goodbye before he turned around to face Dorothy with an odd mixture of dread and anticipation. So she'd come to pacify her guilt, confess to him that she was walking out with Wallenstein, then leave. Despite this bitter realisation, to have her here and to talk to her sparked a small, brief joy within him. That, and deep down a tiny ember of hope burned (she wasn't with Wallenstein, actually Missy had been mistaken, it was him that she wanted).
She looked just as he remembered, of course; for it had not been so very long since he'd seen her last. Dark bob, in contrast to pale, perfect skin. Eyes the colour of absinthe or maybe the light through the leaves in Central Park. Though she was the one who had come to visit, he felt out of place in his own apartment; barefooted, five o'clock shadow accentuating the angles of his face, shirt untucked.
Crossing his arms, Ben stood awkwardly by the door and resisted the urge to light another cigarette. The last time she'd been here the sun had been streaming in at the window but now it rained. Drops pattered against the thin panes of glass at his window and the faint sounds of cars splashing through puddles filtered up from the street below.
"Hey, sheba," he said and there was an unsummoned undercurrent of coldness in his tone. He prepared to blot out the ember. "How're ya doing?"
Dorothy had been wrong. Dead wrong. Earlier that day she had strongly felt that seeing Missy was far worse than seeing Ben himself. After all, he'd filled her with bitterness and pain the last time they'd been together and those icy feelings didn't sit well whereas Missy hadn't done a thing wrong. Upon seeing Ben's face, that ice quickly melted into a pool of uncertainty and guilt that also failed to sit well. She had been wrong indeed.
His use of the term 'sheba' stung. Just a common place nickname, right? Dorothy's eyes instantly flew to his as he coldly ushered the term that she'd only days ago swooned over, searching for malice, anger, or pain. She wasn't sure what she saw in his pale eyes.
"How kind of you to ask, Ben. I'm well, how are you?" Dorothy let the question hang heavily in the air. Her green gaze held his firmly, and she wondered how this meeting would end. How would it even begin? What was it that she wished to accomplish anyway? She was starting to regret making to venture in the first place. Instead she stepped a bit farther into the apartment, letting her eyes trail over a more well developed mess than the last time she'd visited. She couldn't help but eye the disheveled bed that Josephine Levard had been draped on, and frowned at the tinge of jealously that flared when she did so. "We had another meeting with the Italian thugs who threatened George before. Well, only one came to the stand today. It was still just as unnerving, what with him leering at myself and Maddie."
Idle banter? Small talk? Dorothy wasn't sure why she was beating around bushes, but she honestly didn't know how to set about a discussion that would hopefully bring her the closure she sought after. She purposefully avoided the next sentence that would follow in sequence: But fortunately Charlie was there to back Clyde up.
Dorothy peeled her attention away from the bed and back to regarding Ben - as painful as it was, "I didn't mean to interrupt anything here. Jo and Marty didn't have to leave on my account. Is it a bad time?" She half hoped he'd say yes and toss her out the door. Maybe then she could say she'd given it an honest effort and tried to resolve things.
Ben didn't bother to answer her sarcasm-laced enquiry as to his well-being; that obviously wasn't what she was here for. He watched her look around at the mess of papers, ashtrays, books and coffee cups that surrounded her and frown. He'd never before felt apologetic or ashamed for his... haphazard way of life but both of these emotions were creeping up on him now. He'd be willing to bet that Wallenstein's place didn't look like this. He'd bet he didn't smoke too much or drink too much overly-expensive coffee or walk in his socks through a busy New York street to coax a few words out of a gangster for a story that might never run. He'd bet he was out there right now, spreading truth, justice and apple-pie or whatever bushwa the fuzz were pushing these days.
As she apologised for intruding on Marty and Jo's visit, he shrugged and shook his head, feeling the resentment begin to trickle away. Was there ever a good time to be told he'd been dumped by the only dame who, well, who'd cared about this much, for a tall, irritatingly good-looking cop with a past straight out of a pulp novel and the kind of righteous naivety Ben didn't think he'd ever possessed?
He frowned as she hestitantly made small-talk about one of George's bimbo 'friends' and could not help but feel a twinge of concern. The debt collectors for the Italians (or any of New York's numerous gangs) were a bunch of vicious bastards. Ben had worked on many a story starting with an innocent loan or gambling debt and ending with a Harlem sunset down a backalley and a terrified widow left with nothing.
"Maybe you should call the fuzz, sheba," he said, pointedly, making it clear he knew about her and Wallenstein. He met her eyes. Something tugged unbearably underneath his ribs and he was struck with the sudden urge to first demand to know what had made her choose Wallenstein over him, then to kiss her. Perhaps just the last one. He probably didn't need to know the answer to the first.
Ben's pointed comment was well taken.
"Maybe I should call the fuzz, Ben. A novel idea." Dorothy couldn't help but let herself chuckle a bit at Ben's joke. Her short chuckle quickly turned into stomach pinching laughter, which surely made her look slightly off her rocker. When it eased up a bright smile lit her face, though the corners of her eyes still showed the underlying pain this moment brought her.
"We never have had trouble with sarcasm, did we?" In fact, joking and playful banter characterized much of their relationship. In fact, it hardly seemed that they could ever be very serious. The one time she'd tried to ask about the direction their relationship was going, she'd received a kiss. Well, kisses and humor only got you so far. "Perhaps that was part of the problem."
Dorothy's thoughts now quickly spun to the recent discord they'd experienced in The Gin Blossom. At that point, Charlie was just beginning to be a possibility on her horizon with his sweet nature, willingness to help her at any juncture, and boyish charm. It was only that night that Charlie had first hinted at having an interest in her. And when Dorothy had tried to approach Ben..."Or were you under the impression that there were no problems? With us, I mean." She paused, her smile fading away. "Anyway, I saw Missy today on her bike. That's why I'm here."
Being here, so near the man she'd first held interest for and had fully intended on pursuing that interest, made her decision favoring Charlie seem less stable. Less founded. She'd somehow quickly forgotten how fun and funny Ben could be. Sure, Charlie was funny too. He tipped over boats and ate ants, after all! But Ben wasn't even close to the 'bad 'guy' she'd chosen to imagine after that last night near the stairs of the Gin Blossom.
At first, Ben stared at Dorothy as if she had gone off her rocker.
But her laughter was infectious and a grin caught at the corners of his mouth, even if there remained a bitterness in the lines about his eyes. Sure, it had been a joke, but it was on him.
Had it been a problem? The thing was, Ben didn't have anything to compare it to. His previous relationships had been brief and rarely 'serious'. To him, to be deadly serious was to sap the vitality out of anything. He was used to playful flirtation, to casualness. But he was beginning to realise that this was not the case for Dorothy. She had been married before (he'd found this out from an interested Missy a week or so back). She would be used to stability. She might have been married for years. Ben had never been out with a doll for longer than a few months and he felt wrong-footed when confronted with the need to talk about something like this.
But, damn it, he could have adjusted. Just like Dorothy, through her persona of Birdie, was adjusting. She just hadn't given him the chance before Wallenstein had turned up and offered, presumably, what she wanted.
"Maybe," he said, awkwardly ruffling his fingers through the hair on the back of his head. "But you conjured a few more out of thin air before we could do anything about them."
Impulsively, he moved away from the door, towards her. But, hastily checking himself, went into the cluttered kitchen instead. There he began to rinse a couple of the coffee mugs from before and turned the stove on.
"So," he said, far more lightly that he felt. "You wouldn't have come here if Missy hadn't seen you, huh, sheba? You want some coffee, by the way?"
He didn't really want some more java but this gave him something to do, short of lighting up another gasper.
Or making a move on another mac's dame.
For a moment after Ben's response, Dorothy had felt that he was going to move towards her. Her thin frame straightened a little with rigidity, and she tried to prepare herself for being even closer in proximity than they already were. Apparently she had misjudged, as Ben clearly was only moving into the kitchen. He set about preparing a pot of joe.
"So you're going to move right in for the guilt trip, huh?" Dorothy countered, answering his last question with an inquiry of her own. Why was she being so defensive? With a sigh she shook her head, "It wasn't just Missy that made me come. I wanted to...have been wanting to. It might have taken a few days more if she hadn't rode by as I was trying so hard to stay angry at you."
But now she wasn't angry with him. At least, not angry with him in the same way or over the same things as she had been when she'd started out for his apartment. When it came to arguments, such as the one they'd heatedly shared in the stairwell, Dorothy forgave and recovered quickly. It had been like pulling teeth, trying to hold a grudge for the past days since she'd seen him. Now the anger was replaced with a wariness that Dorothy wasn't sure how to recover from.
"You don't have to make coffee, Ben. Playing host isn't really your thing, I've gathered."
"I might not be able to make a four course meal but I can manage a cup of joe. Just about," Ben said, his back to her as he set the pot onto the hot stove. He ignored her comment about the guilt trip, which certainly had an element of truth.
The rich smell of coffee rose into the air to fill the cramped apartment and he stared at the green tiles on the wall in front of him before he forced himself to turn around.
She was still standing there, tension shot through her slender limbs, and he could feel a similar tension in his own muscles as he leaned back against the counter next to the coffee pot that was beginning to funnel steam. He wasn't sure he bought that she'd been wanting to come here. What had she come here to do, anyway? Tell him she was with Wallenstein? Because it was obvious that he already knew. Did really she think that by telling him herself it would soften the blow rather than make it ten times worse?
Don't kid yourself, Goldberg, he told himself, deep down. You'd rather have another chance to see her, even if she is going to rub salt in the wound, than not see her at all.
"I still don't get-" he began, about to launch into a rehash of the argument down in the Gin Blossom. How that had managed to come about in the first place was still hazy in his mind. But what did it matter now whether she thought he had kissed Jo? She was with Wallenstein.
"Actually, forget it. Why are you here, Dorothy?" he said, finally. Any humour in his tone, bitter or not, had evaporated and he merely sounded tired.
Aromatics of quality coffee soon filled the kitchen and Dorothy realized that perhaps, a good cup of brew was just what she needed on such dreary day. Plus, a mug in hand often gave the one the advantage of biding time while taking a long sip of hot liquid.
Unfortunately, a mug didn't make it into her palms before Ben could stab right at the heart of her visit. Gone were the niceties, evaporated was the sarcasm; now his voice seemed to plead simply for answers. His 'why are you here' came across more as 'let's just get this over with.' Ben's stature matched this attitude as he looked tired and ready to give up. Though what there was to give up Dorothy wasn't sure.
"So eager to have me leave then, hm? You can finish your question you know. What is it that you still don't get?" She raised an eyebrow at Ben, wondering what he was wondering. If his thoughts mirrored her own at all, he was still trying to sort out all the confusions of their previous altercation. Though he didn't sound willing to take the time to work through. "It's exactly for questions like that one that I came here in the first place. Regardless of what you heard from Missy about a certain detective, I do care about you. I do care to not have discord and animosity hanging between us."
Dorothy hoped she wasn't coming across as implying anything in the wrong direction. By saying she cared for Ben she wasn't denying her relationship with Charlie and insinuating that what he'd heard from Missy was wrong. She was simply saying that regardless of the presence or absence of romance in their relationship, he meant something to her and she wasn't comfortable leaving things on a bad note.
"Eager for you to leave?" Ben shook his head incredulously then turned back round to pour the coffee from the pot into two waiting mugs. Steam rose from them as they filled with dark liquid. "Bushwa, sheba, I don't want you to-" He frowned and put down the pot with a clunk onto the countertop. If there had been a motivation to wanting to get to the crux of things, it was not because he wanted her to leave. It was because he wanted to say whatever it was she had to say about her and Wallenstein as soon as possible so he could get it over and done with. Like ripping a sticking plaster off in one tug rather than drawing it out by skirting around the subject.
"Look," he said, as his stomach clenched uncomfortably at 'I do care about you'. Just not enough, huh, sheba? was on the tip of his tongue but he bit it back. "What I don't get is what happened in the first place. It's not like I went to the Gin Blossom for the quality of the gigglewater. I went to see you. But then you brush me off and accuse me of necking with Levard before, I guess, throwing yourself into Wallenstein's arms."
He took his mug, leaving Dorothy to take hers from the kitchen counter, then went to sit on the edge of his desk, dislodging a few papers that drifted down to the floor.
"So, do you want me to say that it's fine, sheba? 'Cause I can, if it will make you feel better about yourself." That was too far, Ben knew as soon as the words had left his mouth, but he was angry that she had apparently only come here out of a combination of pity and to tie up guilty loose ends.
Dorothy tried to listen with a measured expression; one that allowed him to speak his thoughts in what must certainly be uncomfortable circumstances. It didn't appear as though Ben was awfully good at expressing such things in the first place, let alone in front of the girl he'd lost to another guy. So as he vented in frustrations from that infamous evening at the Gin Blossom she tried to remain empathetic. Tried.
His last comment, starting with the throwing of her person into Charlie's arms and ending with what might as well have been a slap across the face, broke her otherwise successful cool. His words hurt; trapping her between a desire to dash out of his apartment, throw the scalding coffee at him and shout, or cry. She should have known that trying to work things out with Ben wouldn't carry easily.
Dorothy slowly pulled her hand back from the mug she was about to grab, feeling nothing like the sort of company that could comfortably accept coffee from her host. She tucked a fallen strand of hair behind her ear, pursed her lips, and met Ben with a square gaze.
"I'd prefer that you call me Dorothy." She said slowly. Coldly. Sarcasm oozed around her next sentences,"And yes, Ben. You must have such fast spinning gears in that head of yours. I was coming over simply for absolution so if you cold just quickly give it to me, I'll be on my way back into my lovers arms."
Just as quickly as she'd shifted from cold to sarcastic, her tone now rose in pitch with anger as well as volume, "Do you really have to be such a child? This is precisely why we never got anywhere, Ben! My effort goes to waste with your untimely two-bit jokes and denial. You close yourself off and refuse to commit. Well then fine, but don't say that I haven't tried. I've tried all along only to have you storm away from me in the market, and then dash away from me in the stairwell. If this weren't your apartment, I'm sure you'd be running away again. I am always chasing after you in order to resolve conflict. It is you who should be pursuing me. Charlie doesn't run. He fights for me, Ben. Fights!"
Dorothy was now trembling, the last sentence followed by an aggravated cry.
"I'd prefer that you call me Dorothy."
Ben felt like George had just given him another right hook. With one sentence she'd deftly knocked down and stamped on what had started out as a term of flirtation but had quickly turned into one of affection. He too left his coffee where it sat and stood up suddenly out of hurt and anger. The desk wobbled, sending coffee spilling onto his papers but he didn't seem to notice.
Truth rang in her words. Yeah, he probably had been too quick to turn and walk on some occasions (even if on others, he'd had half the Irish mob chasing him). But what about her? She was no angel, no matter how high the pedastal that Wallenstein had put her on was. And he didn't mind; she was still her. This was New York City, not a fairytale.
"So it should always be me running after you? Even when you veer from one persona to the next, swapping between macs each time? Or am I being childish to think that it's not all my fault?" he said, also raising his voice. He took a step towards her, closing the distance between them. There was an unusual anger in Ben's normally good-natured pale blue eyes.
"You didn't give me a chance to fight, Dorothy! What do you want me to do? You want me to tell you I'd happily cool Wallenstein if I got the chance? Because I'm pretty sure all that would do earn me a pair of bracelets and six months in the clubhouse. You want me to tell you I've been going crazy sitting at that stupid typewriter since the night at the Gin Blossom? Because this crap is testament to that," he said, furiously grabbing a pile of papers and dropping them back on the bed.
"You want me to tell you you're the best thing that's happened to me since I first picked up a damn pen? Because it looks like it's too late for that; you- you've made your decision..." Ben trailed off, surprise at his outburst shaking a wearing down a little of his anger. He looked away.
Dorothy listened to Ben rant, his own tone and demeanor raising to match her own fury. She detested fighting and avoided conflict if possible, but at least they were getting somewhere. The flash in his blue eyes as he stomped towards her at least showed that he gave a care. He lifted a handful of papers, tossing them behind him with a frustrated comment or two about his inability to compose anything decent. She frowned, unsure of what his poor writing had to do with her. Was he blaming Dorothy for this too?
While Ben looked away, his anger giving away slightly to wariness again, Dorothy milled over all that he'd just shouted. He'd made a few more ridiculously sarcastic comments, such as getting sent to jail for accosting Charlie, but she tried to sort through these for the actual accusations and tried to address them one by one. Did she want him to always run after her?
"No, Ben! It's not that you should always be running after me. God, you're dramatic! It's that you were never running after me. I tried to ask you what we were and you did a great job of giving me a heart stopping kiss. But for a man that makes a living out of spinning words, you sure didn't have many for me. "
Was it all his fault? Was she playing two fields, pretending back and forth between Dorothy and Birdie just for her gain? Stringing men along and dumping them when she'd had her fill? Absolutely not. Dorothy was certain that she'd never anticipated Charlie becoming an interest, and had only agreed to date him after seeing Ben kiss Jo...which apparently she had only imagined happening. Then again, she did enjoy being Birdie by night. It gave her a freedom away from the sweet, composed, Dorothy by day. She took a deep breath, not liking where her thoughts were heading.
"I have a part in this too, Ben. I'm not placing all the blame on you. But I'm saying I tried. I tried to approach you in the Gin Blossom even after I'd seen you kiss Jo...er- well, after I thought I saw you kiss Jo. But I got the cold shoulder... and if I'd known..."
And if she'd known the kiss hadn't happened? If she hadn't argued with Ben right before going to dinner with Charlie, what would have happened? Did this all mean that she'd chosen Charlie out of anger for Ben? No, it wasn't that extreme. Her feelings for the detective were real. But maybe she hadn't given Ben enough of a chance. After all, it was while living the Birdie-life that she loved that she had met Ben in the first place. Singing at a speakeasy wasn't exactly copacetic with dating a cop.
"Ben..." Dorothy too trailed off, not knowing where to go now in their conversation. She didn't want to hear that she was the best thing that had ever happened to him. Wouldn't believe it, as they hardly knew each other. "You think by phrasing questions, that you're not telling me? Apparently you're still holding hope that it's not too late." She rubbed a hand across her face, and stepped away. His closeness was more than she could handle and it felt too close to be appropriate.
Ben continued looking at a point somewhere a foot to the left of Dorothy's shoulder. She was wrong. Words were cheap. He knew that well enough; he'd written millions of them. Mountains of sweet-nothings, every cliche in the damn book, endless reams of saccharine dialogue; it was all worth jack in the end. If there wasn't a spark, some indefinable mutal equality of thought and feeling then what the hell did it matter? You were just kidding yourself. Sure, some people were fine with that, some people kidded themselves for years. But Ben had felt his way through the relationship, if you could call it that, with Dorothy with the easy assumption that she would be doing the same, rather than needing some kind of confirmation from him that this wasn't just a fling that would start and finish in some speakeasy.
Maybe Ben wasn't good enough with words. At the time he had thought that a kiss, an introduction to what was left of his family would communicate to Dorothy what she meant to him and thought no more about it. Apparently, he had been wrong.
Maybe he'd feel the same way if he'd lost a spouse so young.
She stepped away and he felt the distance between them gape wide again. Managing to meet her eyes, he too stepped back and leant uneasily against the edge of his desk. Now that the anger had almost evaporated, he was beginning to feel like a first prize pill.
"Is it?"
He was almost certain he knew what the answer would be. The ember was dying a quiet death.
Dorothy returned his disheartened stare, letting several long seconds pass by. Dorothy knew the answer to this question, knew what he was asking. The answer flashed into her head instantly, because in the time that Ben had been contemplating the usefulness of words, Dorothy had been remembering where she was at exactly the same time one evening before: Daisy Wallenstein's house.
It wasn't the warm and inviting dinner Mrs. Wallenstein had prepared. It wasn't the jokes she'd volleyed with Charlie's sisters about the danger prone detective. Nor was it the sweet kisses or the hints of his love for her that caused her to make her decision. It was the quickly whispered words that Dorothy had confided in Charlie's father, and all that had provoked her to utter those secret words. Regardless of family, friends, or other factors...Dorothy knew Charlie meant more to her than she knew how to express. This realization scared her near to death; caring about someone that much...well, it just wasn't easy. Dorothy had already gone down that road; fell in love, got married, moved to the city...and lost it all. She wasn't sure she was willing to put herself through even the memory of those emotions again. But regardless of her fears and what would or would not happen with the detective, the answer to Ben's question was glaringly and painfully obvious.
"Is it too late, you mean? Yes." Her answer came quietly. If it would have been even the slightest bit appropriate, she would have hugged him. Worry filled her features, but she remained where she was. "I know you believe that I switch masks and men, but I hope you see that isn't true. I invited both you and Charlie into my night and day. Birdie and Dorothy aren't separate entities; they sing the same songs. It's you and I, Ben, that were on different stanzas."
Dorothy finally looked away. When she spoke again, she tried to keep her voice from cracking. She tried to will the tears from building with a painful pressure in the corners of her eyes. Despite her choice, Ben remained significant and her words were piercing her own heart, "I'm sorry...if I've hurt you, I mean. I never meant for, well, any of this but I especially didn't mean to hurt you."
Ben heard the word he was expecting to hear and, even though he'd been anticipating it, the blow was not softened. It was as if as someone had grabbed him at a point somewhere underneath his ribs and twisted. He crossed his arms over his chest and looked down at his bare feet against the bare floorboards.
As much as he felt like launching into a tirade into why Wallenstein was no good for her, that if she and Ben were on different 'stanzas', as she had so painfully put it, then her and Wallenstein were playing in different joints, he knew that it wouldn't help. He also knew that, even if the sight of Missy had been the nudge she'd needed towards doing it, her intentions for coming over here were good. Ben didn't like the idea of leaving things untied and resentful any more than she did but, at the same time, he didn't know if he could be around her purely as a friend whilst pretending everything was fine.
He had been wrong about her, probably still was. But she had been wrong about him too. And now they wouldn't get the chance to right those wrongs.
"Yeah, I know you didn't," he said, his own voice cracking as he moved his gaze from a knot in the wood of the floorboards to her eyes which were bright with unshed tears. "It's OK, Dorothy." He desperately wanted to embrace her but forced every muscle to remain still. There was silence for a few moments.
"But hey, if you ever change your mind, you know where to find me. If I'm not wearing a Chicago overcoat courtesy of the Muirenns by then, that is," he added, not wanting her to leave when she was like this. He forced a smile and willed another to appear in those green eyes of hers.
Ben's smile did nothing to lighten her countenance, but rather made Dorothy wince with a fresh flood of pain. He was trying so hard to make this easy, now. She could see the strain and sacrifice his every muscle was making, the weight that he was fighting against to keep the corners of his mouth up. A part of her wished he'd thrown her out of his apartment in a tirade of fury and slew of curses; it would have been easier and perhaps a bit earned.
"The Muirenns..." Dorothy parroted his words back to him, still staring at a knot in the wood floor. Fiona Muirenn was another element of her life she'd have to cut out with Charlie at her side. Not that she and Fiona were on close terms, but Dorothy (or Birdie, rather) had been introduced to Fiona's close friend Jack and had even been harkened by Fiona for a private discussion. Certain events, such as a raging bar fight, kept that meeting from happening. But Dorothy wouldn't fixate on this now.
"No, Ben, it really isn't OK. Neither of us will walk away from this feeling OK about things, despite all the good intentions in the world. You're sweet to try that line, though. And if I ever changed my mind, well-" Dorothy shook her head, finally lifting her pained eyes to meet Ben's. She took a timid step forward, the distance between them still wide enough, but she couldn't stand still any longer. "My coming back to you would register like a punch to the stomach. You wouldn't want to me after I got my fill of someone else. Not only would it confirm what you said about me swapping macs," Dorothy's lips twitched briefly, "but it would make you cheap."
She finally allowed a small smile to grace her features, though it was probably appeared rather sad, "And you're not cheap, Ben."
Ben watched as she repeated his sentence uselessly and took the smallest of steps forward. Though he didn't want to, he remained where he was, instead uncrossing his arms and the lean fingers of one hand tapped soundlessly against the grain of the wooden desk. They were the only external sign of an internal agitation.
He privately thought her coming back to him would register like a fix of snow rather than a punch in the stomach.
Ben shrugged, and forced another grin. But this one came easier than the last but for some reason, brought tears closer to welling in his eyes than before. He successfully fought them back and ran his fingers awkwardly through his unruly hair.
"I could be," he said. The words for you were implicit but too close to cliche for him to allow himself to say out loud.
Pause. He looked at her, gaze travelling over every feature, every blemish on her pale skin, every laughter line about her eyes, every shadow at her throat and every plane of her figure. He supposed that this would be the last time he would ever spend alone with her and was determined to etch it into his consciousness as vividly as any scene he had ever written.
"But I'm glad you don't think so," he added, finally.
Dorothy tried to read the expression on Ben's face as he spoke the words, I could be, leaving them to trail off before concluding. She couldn't tell if he was reviving sarcasm, being serious, or hovering in some grey area between the two. In any case, Dorothy would feel nothing less than a bully if she were to come flying back to the writer's side if she ever grew tired of walking out with the man of law. Her petite figure struggled to maintain compsure as Ben dragged his eyes over her in entirity. Under different cicumstances with a different fellow, she'd have rushed forward to offer a swift slap across the face. But she could tell his lingering gaze bore no indecency, but perhaps a good measure of melancholy.
"It would be impossible for me to do so..." She said candidly, an honest smile lighting her face. Then Dorothy folded her arms, pressed her pink lips together, and let her eyes rove his living quarters as though a handy sentence or easy farewell would be scrawled along the wall for her disposal. Where was she to go from here? Though she had nothing more on the topic to say, things seemingly resolved as she had so wanted, neither did she have the voice or heart to yeild another conversation. It wouldn't carry the same to start speaking of friendly things after all that had just transpired, at least not yet. Departing seemed the most viable option, but Dorothy found her heart grounding her feet to the wooden floorboards beneath her.
"I guess I'm not sure what happens from here. I don't know if I will see you around or not...because I'd like to. Really, I would. The Gin Blossom and our produce stand, well...they're always open to you, Ben. If you want to or can bring yourself to visit, that is. We've been through a lot..." Once more her words trailed off. The green eyed woman could feel her heart pounding slowly but forcefully in her chest. A peace, truce, middle ground, or whatever the hell they wanted to call it had been reached. Who knew that this would be the most difficult part? Standing there, watching Ben, watching Ben watch her...knowing that once she walked away, nothing could or would ever be the same; the essence of decision making. She wanted to cultivate their friendship, because regardless of her choice, there was so much that she appreciated about Ben. But would he want the same? "I suppose this is the part where I leave, then. Right? Can I...would it be too much if...?"
Well, for all that had happened, Dorothy realized she didn't care about decencies. She had cared and did care about him, afterall, and at the core of who she was Dorothy couldn't just stand idly by while it was so obvious that the both of them were hurting. He could shove her away if he wanted to, but Dorothy was willing to take that risk, and traversed the remaning distance between them to envelope him in what would likely be their last embrace.
Ben tried his best to look as if he was considering the idea of coming to see her at her stall or at the Gin Blossom. The former was definitely not going to happen. As much as he wanted to speak to her again, seeing her in that context with Wallenstein would be unbearable. As for the latter... Perhaps. Once the fuss with the Muirenns had died down, when the wound was feeling a little less tender he might venture down into the dark warmth of Shin's joint and stand at the bar to watch Birdie perform. But he'd force himself to leave before the end, so he didn't have the time to drink the amount of firewater that would make going backstage seem like a sensible idea.
He met her smile with a grin of his own, summoned from his last reserve. Now that the conversation was over, what he'd both been dreading, yet knew was going to happen, had happened, he suddenly didn't want her to go. He could start up some painfully trivial conversation, or ask her if the coffee he'd made was going to go to waste, or...
Ben's train of thought was interrupted by her unexpected embrace. He felt her hands on his back, between his shoulder blades and her thin frame against his own lean one. Gingerly at first, but then with more strength, he put his arms around her. He was struck with the physical paradox of somehow needing to feel closer to her whilst nearly being as close as possible. Emotionally, he supposed, there was no paradox.
"You trying to make this as hard as possible, sh- Dorothy?" he said, a smile in his voice as he spoke into her hair. He turned his head inwards ever so slightly, mouth almost at her temple. It took Ben every ounce of self-control to maintain that almost. Hell, giving up gaspers would be easy compared to this, Goldberg, he thought as he turned to face forwards again and looked down at her at his shoulder.
Words wouldn't even begin to express the relief that Dorothy felt when Ben returned her embrace. Though she'd been prepared to feel hands on her shoulders pushing her away to arms length, demanding her departure, she favored this outcome much better. It meant that he accepted that she still cared for him. It meant that he still cared for her. Most of all, it meant that she'd gauged correctly in assuming that - despite all things- they were still able to offer one another solace.
She let her lashes flutter down over bright eyes, squeezing them tightly closed while breathing in deeply to take in the moment, the comfort, the meaning. The pounding against her ribcage receded gradually with each inhale, her tight embrace less tense upon every exhale.
"This already is as hard as possible," Catching the bit of smile in his tone Dorothy volleyed it back, though her statement held nothing humorous. Dorothy lifted her head from his shoulder and tilted it back enough to smile up into his gentle eyes. Were anyone to walk into this scene they'd assume quite the opposite of what was actually happening. "I was mad when I told you not to call me sheba, ya' know. That shouldn't stop."
The time had well passed for her to draw away, rather than continue to read the unspoken sentences in his pale gaze. But still Dorothy didn't want to let go. There had come to be a handful of occurrences in Dorothy's life where she wished to freeze the spinning world. Moments she wanted to sink into. Live in. Moments she wanted to tear apart to observe from every angle, mull over meaning and choice, and then piece back together again like the delicate puzzle of human nature and emotion that it was. When she'd received her first kiss, upon opening the door to learn of Wayne's death, the end of her first song sung on stage...this now added to the compilation of memories that Dorothy would draw out and rediscover many times later when alone and wistful.
Another crooked and awkward smile bent the corner of Dorothy's lips as she, once again, struggled to find direction from here. She couldn't stay in another man's arms all day, after all. Her words came slowly, "So...Ben..." She adjusted her arms, bringing them out from around his body to rest lightly on his shoulders. The smallest of steps backwards created a small gap between their figures, leaving Ben's hands to linger at her waist. In much like a formal dance posture they stood, a fraction closer to ending what had developed into a tender farewell.
"OK," he said, glad she was letting him reclaim his name for her. Let Wallenstein have sweetheart, baby, whatever he wanted, as long as sheba was his.
"But maybe only when it's just the two of us, huh, sheba?" he added, looking back down at her as she lifted her head away from his shoulder. The likely possibility that the two of them would never be alone again was unspoken. It struck him too, that they had been in a very similar position, even if the situation had been very different, on this very spot in the middle of his little apartment not so long ago.
She drew back a few inches, taking her lips and the temptation to kiss them a little further away. His hands fell naturally to her narrow hips and they remained there, in tableau, as if about to begin a dance or resume an embrace when, in a way, it would be the complete opposite. Once again, perhaps because he knew that this was another step towards her absence, he began a tirade (though more subdued than the last) in his head about how stupid this was. He sensed a reluctance in her too; he was certain he wasn't imagining it, certain he could see it in her absinthe green eyes.
"So."
He looked back at her, willing a similar smile to come to his own countenance. But it didn't and he met her gaze with a mixture of restrained passion, as if he were about to kiss her or start up another raging argument with her, and resignation.
Dorothy's awkward grin shifted to a sardonic smile, and she shook her head at Ben. Though they were both clearly lacking the desire to move things forward and thus end this rendezvous, one of them would need to set things in motion. Ben, repeating Dorothy's "so", would not be that person.
"Alright then, mister decisive." Dorothy joked, allowing half-hearted mirth to spill over her features. She pretended that she wasn't left breathless by the gaze he returned, and she even poked him in the chest playfully for good measure, when all she wanted to do was collapse the distance between them and tell him how badly she didn't want to leave.
But it was she who had ended things, not Ben, and so it wasn't rightly fair that for her to expect him to save her and gracefully lead her to the door. Feelings were hurt. Emotions were raw. In the end, though, Dorothy had another pair of arms to turn to where Ben did not. For this fact alone she wanted to remain there as long as he needed, but on a second (and painful) though she realized that his need wouldn't have her leaving in the first place. Her smile faltered. Obvious discomfiture was defined in her expression, though she quickly worked to hide it by ducking her head.
Dorothy removed her hands from Ben's shoulders and reached to lift his ink stained hands from her hips. She stood frozen with his hands insider hers for a moment, then let them free and turned abruptly towards the door. Oh, how difficult those steps that carried her to her exit. This wasn't like a normal break off, after all. One of them hadn't cheated on the other, revealed some inexcusable blemish in personality, or issued unforgivable cruelties against the other. They hadn't grown to realize that their personalities clashed or that their values were mismatched. It was like claiming dislike of a dish, when you hadn't even tasted it. If it weren't for knowing that her heart was held in such perfect care by someone else, this would be truly impossible. But Charlie was there, even if that fact brought Dorothy a new round of uncertainty.
"So..." She returned conversation to finish both of their sentences. "Which sort of farewell do we choose? Do I simply bid you adieu, or shake your hand, or promise until next time?" She fixed him with her green eyed gaze again, determined to keep her chin up and leave with a smile.
Ben didn't say anything in reply to Dorothy's half-baked joke nor did he flinch or try to playfully dodge her poke at his chest. He didn't really feel like joking now. Instead, he watched her unloop her arms from his neck and take his hands into her smaller ones, bowing her head to conceal her expression. He felt compelled to lift up her chin so he could meet her gaze but he barely had enough time to stroke his thumb over the back of her hand before she'd ripped them away and started towards the door.
He went after her automatically but faltered. Perhaps he should just let her open the door and go without a proper goodbye. Quick and (relatively) painless. Like ripping off a band aid, just like he'd thought to himself before. Yeah, keep telling yourself that, Goldberg. Keep pretending like the way that you go about this is important when the end result is going to be the same, no matter what you do.
She turned around and willed a smile into her eyes, keeping up with a Birdie-style narration as if they were in a movie at the picture palace and her words were about to be shown, neatly typed on a board, whilst the band down in the pit forced melodrama from their instruments. He didn't much like the sound of any of the choices she gave him.
On impulse, he bent down and kissed her.
It was not the sort of kiss they'd shared in the street after they went to Missy's place but an onlooker would not be able to truthfully say it was platonic either. Not from the way he looked at her before their lips met. Not from the way it lasted just a little too long than would be appropriate between friends.
He kissed her at the corner of her mouth, where her soft lips narrowed and joined gracefully at their edges, next to where lines formed when she smiled. It only lasted a second or two but the silence for those brief moments was crystalline. As he drew back their noses touched.
"I'll see ya around, Dorothy," Ben said.
At first, Ben didn't answer and for a while Dorothy assumed that he wasn't going to play along. She guessed that her attempts to keep things light and 'easy' were unwanted by the journalist, with none of the options she'd offered being desirable. So she'd have to leave the hard way, she assumed, placing her hand on the doorknob.
Dorothy had assumed wrong. She wasn't going to have to leave the hard way, she was going to have to leave the excruciating way. Though no words fell from Ben's lips, his lips fell to hers. She was, of course, taken by surprise. Her posture tensed again and she felt she couldn't move until he pulled away. Her eyes slowly, slowly, lifted to scan his face- searching with slight trepidation. Her long fingers reached to gently touch his cheek; even she was unsure of what her gesture meant.
Had their lips met full on, Dorothy wasn't sure what she'd have done. She wouldn't have kissed him back, but this kiss saved her from worrying about it. Ben's kiss, though obviously not traditional for a friendly farewell, could be feigned as so. So Dorothy pretended that the way his lips met hers was completely polite; nothing to fret about. A graceful smile touched her lips and she pulled her hand away from his face. A quick return peck was placed on his cheek before she twisted the handle, pushed open the door, and stepped away.
"I hope you do, Ben. Soon." Without waiting for his reply, Dorothy finished stepping into the hallway and tugged his door closed. The last thing she wanted now -aside from another unsettling kiss- was to know that he was watching her retreat. Down the stairs and into the damp streets of New York city, Dorothy finally allowed a lone tear to trace her cheek before she caught it at her jawline with a finger, and wiped away the last trace of her altercation with Benjamin Goldberg.
-------A Week Later-------------
“Are you absolutely sure this will all work out? I need you to be sure.”
“Stop worrying your lip. You’ll make it bleed. Of course I’m sure, Dorothy. Have I ever let ya down before? Trust me, doll, as long as you've secured things with that cousin of yours we’ll be just fine. I meant to ask you if he was a looker. Now lean back.”
Dorothy’s lips seemed permanently pursed, expressing her concern but she obediently tipped her head back over the farmer’s basin sink in Coraline’s kitchen. How the young woman afforded such a lavish place by her lonesome, the green eyed lounge singer decided she didn’t want to know. A putrid odor encompassed the room making her eyes water and nostrils flair in protest, but all in all she didn’t much care. If it worked, it was worth it.
Just under a week ago Dorothy stopped caring all together. Upon fleeing Ben Goldberg’s apartment she quickly made her way to Charlie’s place, hoping to find a welcoming pair of arms to sooth and comfort her. She’d just broken it off with Ben in a fashion that nearly tore her to pieces. His blue eyes had been pleading, piercing a spot in her chest so strongly that she’d had to wince and gasp for a deep breath whenever she brought the memory to recollection. As it turned out, her beau Charlie’s arms weren’t as comforting as she had hoped. Charlie’s boyish smile and good intentions spelled out her future as plain as day, a future she realized she didn’t want; marriage, a white picket fence, and toddling children clinging to the hems of her skirts. She’d been down that road once with Wayne, now deceased. Hadn’t she found a new lifestyle that completely contradicted what Charlie offered? In a near panic, Dorothy had removed his arms from around her and offered profuse apologies. Surely a gal would be hard pressed to find an honest man like Charlie, but his hints and love and a pastoral future gave Dorothy an acute relational claustrophobia. And so she'd ditched two suitors in one day.
“Golly, is there even anything left of my hair? I’ve lost all sensation!” Dorothy cried. Her fingers were wrapped tightly around the arms of the chair she occupied, longing to reach up and tear at her burning scalp.
“Cool it, will ya?” Cora scrubbed furiously at Dorothy’s sopping wet hair, staining a towel with the colorful chemicals that rubbed off. Once satisfied with the result she drew away, regarding Dorothy with a pleased smirk on her face. “Aww, lady, it’s beautiful! People will surely mistake us for sisters, you and I. You were meant to be a redhead miss Byrd.”
“Then why was I born otherwise?” Dorothy sneered.
The plan now was to leave New York city together; Dorothy and Cora. A cousin in New Orleans offered the two woman not only a place to stay, but a pair of occupations to keep them busy and financed. His correspondence had already spoken of his refusal to accept rent from family, and also stated that a friend of Dorothy's was as good as family. She'd struck upon the idea after speaking with Clyde, who mentioned that George wasn't the only family member to be dabbling in illegal activities. Family rumor had it that their cousin, Otto Newbury, was keeping company with shady characters and speak easy owners in the Louisiana city. What her family saw as atrocity, Dorothy saw as opportunity. Though she doubted they'd heard of the singing birdie that far south, her familiarity with the lounge scene and Otto's connections might just be the new chance that she needed to escape a city that bore her not one, or two...but three stories of heartache.
"Remind me of why I decided to accompany you and your sour attitude to some southern city we've never been to?" Cora asked, tossing Dorothy a fiery look. With hands propped on her slender hips and foot tapping, she looked more like a teen throwing a fit than a threat.
"Because going with me and my sour attitude gets you away from that no good boyfriend who takes to slapping you around. Not to mention a change of scenery. New York just doesn't do it for me anymore, and I can't go alone. We both agreed to a fresh start." It was Cora's idea that, if Dorothy wanted a fresh start, she should go all out. And in the sassy, cigarette seller's mind, that meant dying Dorothy's hair a shade of red to match her own. "And it won't be fresh long if we don't get going. Grab your bags, the train leaves in three hours and we've still got to pay Clyde a visit."
Last edited by
whiteangel on Mon Jun 29, 2009 8:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.