He'd wounded her. He'd insulted her. As his lips were pressed to hers once more, her heart was sore with the weight of the revelation of something she knew all along. As his forehead was leaned against hers, the lovely smell of the cologne she'd given him last Christmas on his skin filling her nose, she held back a painful sob.
"You know what? I... I knew all along," she said shakily. "And what hurt the most wasn't just expecting you to tell me. It was my putting off all the opportunities to tell you. I loved you once. I loved you so much... But I never told you that I did because I didn't want to lose a best friend and brother figure. Two important people to me for one I'm not even sure I'll last my life with."
She pushed him away gently, her smaller hands trying their best to force him away from her.
"Just... Just go away. The last thing I need is another lover."
She turned away from him and walked toward the startled party, having witnessed what happened between the two, seated not too far away. She bit her lip, trying not to cry, and approached her Aunt Abbie, who had immediately grabbed the young woman's hand to comfort her.
"Abby..." she said, acknowledging her sadness.
"Aunt Abbie, can I use one of your rooms? I... I need to be alone for a while."
"Alright... But, are you going to be okay?"
"Y-y... Yeah. I think s-so."
She let go of the older woman's hand and started off with a walk, which quickened as soon as she neared the back door. She pushed Sam away and rushed inside, running upstairs and going to the nearest room she could find and locked it.
She'd never cried her heart out like that before. The tears wouldn't stop flowing, her shaky, sorrow-filled sobs couldn't stop escaping her throat. She cried out all the years of pain that had been building up inside her just this once, for all the days she never cried a tear, even if she had the right to. And she could never tell him how she knew. He didn't need to know. She lay curled up on the floor for ten minutes after the half hour she spent crying before she realized she ended up in the one place she should've never been in — Mr. and Mrs. Larkin's bedroom.
Not even as a child was she allowed here. She'd been told when she was very young that there were monsters here that were very good friends with them. Now, she was grown up, and had her own ideas about monsters. To her surprise, on the edge of Abbie Larkin's vanity drawer was a very nice photograph of her father. The face possessed a true happiness. She couldn't help but hold her long, wavy red hair as she saw her father's reddish blond crown of hair, and stare at the same bright blue eyes. This photo was the very one that she recalled seeing during her father's funeral. She held back more tears as she took the photo in her hands. She flipped the photo over and saw her father's handwriting and a message that made her curious.
Chérie,
Here's something to scare you each morning. I love you so much. See you whenever.
On the table, she saw a journal, with a piece of paper peeking out of it. She opened it and started to read, reaching an entry dated two days after PJ's birthday.
Now she was growing more and more puzzled. This... Was this what Abbie and Connor were trying to hide?
Ben, if only you were here.
She's here... And she's so beautiful...
She has your eyes. I'd like to think that you're still here but... Why did you have to go?